CRT: A rose by any other name…

What’s in a name?  What’s in a definition?  Or the expressed meaning?  Or the perceived meaning?

In education we have seen lots of name changes and as well as shifts in meaning.  Often times a new term/phrase will begin appearing as a euphemism.  One example that many will recognize is the use of College and Career Ready Standards in place of Common Core State Standards.  Are Culturally Responsive Teaching and Culturally Relevant Teaching euphemisms for diversity, equity, and inclusion?  What about diversity, equity, and inclusion?  Has that become a euphemism for CRT?  Is it a coincidence that Culturally Responsive Teaching, Culturally Relevant Teaching, and Critical Race Theory are all CRT?  Not to be confused with Criterion Referenced Test.

In addition to name changes, we have seen shifts in meaning.  While sounding great by the words used, in practice the meaning may be something quite different than that perceived by most folks.  Here are a few examples:

    • Research– Corporate or foundation funded ideological report based on anecdotal evidence and consensus in lieu of empirical evidence
    • Evidence-based– Consensus has been reached without regard or consideration of any evidence
    • Data-driven– Decisions are driven by ways more data about students, parents, and teachers can be obtained
    • Transparency— You are only being told and shown what they want you to hear and see while critical information is being withheld
    • State-led– When states are led to make decisions and policy by non-elected and non-accountable individuals and groups and are non-responsive to the people of their state
    • Education– Workforce pipeline preparation / indoctrination
    • State Sovereignty– A system that allows states to proceed with plans once they have been approved by the federal government

A lot has been written about what Critical Race Theory is and isn’t.  Some of it is spot on and some of it just plain spotty.  Since you can read about what CRT is and isn’t in other places, I won’t go into the various meanings it takes on in the different arenas it has invaded.  CRT seems to have one meaning at the graduate school level.  It has escaped the realm of graduate school and its meaning has taken on Hydra like qualities.

The push for CRT seems to be supported by research, evidence-based, data-driven, and is transparent according the definitions provided above.  In reality (does reality even exist anymore?), I’ve not seen any evidence CRT eliminates racism.  I’ve also not seen any evidence CRT improves academic achievement.  Where’s the evidence the push for diversity, equity, and inclusion will eliminate racism or improve academic achievement?  What ever happened to teaching kids how to read, write, and do arithmetic?

Critical Race Theory.  Theory is in the name.  It’s a theory.  At whatever level one considers, it has not been proven.  So why should various Hydra-like elements of CRT be implemented with elementary students?  Does that amount to indoctrination?  There is precedent for implementing theory in elementary classrooms.  The implementation of Howard Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligence took classrooms by storm.  Like the Theory of Multiple Intelligence, CRT and the diversity, equity, and inclusive effort don’t seem to have much in the way of solid scientific support to back them.  Who cares about scientific support?  Is the passion of fanatics and ideologues enough to render scientific support unimportant or unnecessary?

A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.  What about the meaning of and as put into instructional practice of CRT, diversity, equity, and inclusion?  How does that smell?  Does it pass the sniff test?  There are lots of varieties of roses, some with a sweet smell and some with little to no detectable odor.  What is the odor of CRT, diversity, equity, and inclusion?  Is it like that of a rose or more like stinkweed or skunk cabbage?  Or are there many folks suffering from CRT anosmia that don’t smell a thing?  Of course, that could be blamed on COVID.

What kind of society has an education system that enculturates kids in a way that does not reflect the culture and beliefs of the parents, community, and society at large?

And what about Washington State requiring all school personnel to undergo cultural competency, diversity, equity, and inclusion training?


Posted in Critical Race Theory | Tagged , | Leave a comment

How Common Core Broke U.S. Schools

CNBC’s article States are implementing new educational standards, signaling the end of Common Core included a video worth sharing. The video can also be found on youtube.

The information on youtube says:

First implemented in 2009, Common Core was an ambitious initiative to revolutionize the American education system. National leaders from Bill Gates to President Obama supported the idea and it cost an estimated $15.8 billion to implement. Years later, research showed the new curriculum had minimal impact on student performance. So why did Common Core fail? Can a common curriculum be successful for all students? Watch the video to find out.

Posted in Bill Gates, CCSS, Common Core State Standards, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Combatting Critical Race Theory in Your Community

I found the document Combatting Critical Race Theory in Your Community: An A to Z Guide On How to Stop Critical Race Theory And Reclaim Your Local School Board in a link provided following an article called A Stunning Pushback … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Critical Race Theory Related Resources

Here some resources for those concerned about Critical Race Theory. A page has been set up and will be added to as other resources come to my attention. The page is CRT Related Resources. Resources, Groups, Organizations, & Info Sources … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , | 1 Comment

‘Leftish Agenda In Class’: 15-Year-Old High School Student Exposes Critical Race Theory In Speech

The youtube info says, “15-year-old high school student exposes critical race theory.” You can read more about this in an article titled Student Slams School Board Over Teaching of ‘Woke’ Critical Race Theory.

Posted in Critical Race Theory | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Is Critical Race Theory Legislation Riot Worthy?

What the heck is all the fuss about related to Critical Race Theory (CRT) legislation?  I’ve read articles where teachers and others are complaining that the legislation ties the teacher’s hands and even bans them from teaching history or at … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

What the Heck is Critical Race Theory (CRT)?

I’m back. For nearly a year now, I have taken a break from posting here on The Underground Parent. That doesn’t mean I haven’t been paying attention to issues impacting the education of students all across the country. The pandemic … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Misunderstandings about Understanding in Math

Barry Garelick has produced a very informative evidence-supported instructional practice presentation called Misunderstandings about Understanding for researchED‘s August 2020 Virtual Event. researchED provides this as a brief intro to the presentation: “The issue of balance between procedural fluency and conceptual … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Real Math Teaching and Good Testing Works for All Students

This is a guest post by Ted Nutting. I’m a retired Seattle mathematics teacher.  I’m alarmed by the proposals to address racial bias in our schools by doubling down on “inquiry-based learning” and by doing away with standardized tests.  These … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged | 4 Comments

Wellbeing Checks or Privacy Intrusions?

This gallery contains 1 photo.

Is our education system exhibiting signs of serious mission creep?  At what point has the mission shifted from providing a knowledge-based academic education to conducting wellbeing checks and collecting a wide range of data?  The Tennessee Department of Education appears … Continue reading

More Galleries | Tagged , | 1 Comment